Masking in Lightroom/Camera Raw: Two perspectives

The newest versions of Lightroom (Lr) and Camera Raw (CR) have significantly improved masking capabilities. There are options to make masks based on the subject and the sky, gradient masks, brush masks, and masks based on color ranges and luminance ranges. It’s an interesting and useful collection. In addition, there are ways to add, subtract, intersect, and invert masks, so the new masks can be combined in a variety of ways, similar to the Mask Calculator in the TK8 plugin.

There are lots of YouTube videos demonstrating the basics of using these new masks, so most readers are probably already familiar with their functionality. The two people I work closely with, Sean Bagshaw and Dave Kelly, have both contributed what I feel are some unique perspectives on these masks that I think are worth sharing.

Dave Kelly: Mask-the-mask in Lightroom/Camera Raw

Dave Kelly is someone who is good at taking a deep dive into almost anything and finding a few pearls that others have missed. His weekly “TK Friday” series on YouTube looks at using the TK8 plugin, and, to be honest, he’s pushes it further than I have when testing and using it. In doing so, he’s found new uses for TK8 and has also highlighted some things that can eventually be improved. I’m always glad (and somewhat relieved) to see that TK8 can keep up with what Dave is doing.

One of the techniques he’s demonstrated in various videos in the Friday series is the mask-the-mask technique in Photoshop. The way this generally works is to make an adjustment to the image through a specialized mask, like a luminosity mask or color mask, and then putting the adjustment layer into a group with a black layer mask. Painting on the group’s layer mask with white paint then reveals the adjustment in just those parts of the image where it’s needed. Luminosity and color masks are incredibly useful, of course, but they work on all similarly selected pixels in the image. The mask-the-mask technique allows the adjustment to be selectively applied to specific parts of the image. The process is easy and straightforward in Photoshop and produces a very targeted adjustment.

But, you might wonder, is it possible to replicate this technique with the new masks in Lr/CR? Well, thanks to Dave Kelly, we now know the answer to this question is “Yes,” and Dave shows how to do it in the video below. It’s not as simple as in Photoshop but appears to achieve similar results, namely restricting a color range or luminance range adjustment to specific parts of the image. It uses the Brush tool for making the final reveal, so that’s similar to the Photoshop method. However, it’s a bit more complicated before that. Still, it’s a very clever and insightful use of the new Lr/CR masks . . . and I’m not surprised Dave was able to figure out how to do it. For photographers working exclusively in Lightroom, Dave’s method will likely be a useful new tool in their workflow arsenal. NOTE: Dave doesn’t call this the “mask-the-mask” technique in the video, but, based on the end result, that’s essentially what’s happening.

Sean Bagshaw: Comparing Lr/CR masks with Photoshop masks

I’ve personally not worked extensively enough with the new Lr/CR masks to compare them with masks that can be created with Photoshop and the TK8 plugin, but Sean’s video below specifically undertakes this comparison. Some of the masks, like Select Sky, are basically equivalent in Lightroom and Photoshop according to Sean. Lightroom wins for gradient and radial masks, but Photoshop masks, like those made with the TK8 plugin, offer additional types of masks (saturation, vibrance, color brightness, and edge masks) and additional ways to modify masks. Sean also discusses using smart objects to be able to continually access the best of both types of masks from the two different sources.

The takeaway from Sean’s video, I think, is that there are some new and very useful mask options now available in Lr/CR, but that Photoshop still offers mask options and mask control, along with additional creative techniques not available in Lr/Cr, to continue to make it a valuable part of the workflow. In the end, everyone will use the tools they understand best and that produce the result they’re looking for. And that’s always been the best approach when working creatively with images.

Local Light: Sketch-o-graphs

Fishhook barrel cactuses live up to their name. The spines look like fishhooks and are just as sharp. These, along with the hair-like structures, create an almost abstract covering for this common cactus. Looking closely at the edges, you can see the fine black lines that the sketch actions add.

An earlier post on local light discussed how photographing nearby subjects provides an opportunity to see them in new ways using different techniques, either during the capture phase with the camera or in post-processing. This past summer I decide to more fully explore this approach. My daily walk on the neighborhood streets offers plenty of interesting subjects in the form of Sonoran desert cactuses and other succulents. But I also wanted to do something different photographically with them and had my eye on the sketch technique I learned from Steve Dell. His photos using this technique along with those of Bob Hills made me want to explore this technique to see what works for me. These “sketch-o-graphs” can still look photographic, but they usually have enhanced edges and color. I was also planning to include the sketch action in the TK8 plugin and wanted to gain additional experience using it to insure the plugin included the best practices for getting good results. NOTE: The sketch actions in the TK8 plugin are accessed via the Workflow Extras button on the main interface of the Multi-Mask module (green outline, left image), and this opens a new interface where the Color Sketch and B&W Sketch actions are located.

Choosing the subject

Based on what I saw in Steve’s and Bob’s photos, images with lots of detail and texture seem to be the best candidates for sketches. Things like clouds, moving water, and out-of-focus elements are less affected by this technique. The sketch action finds edges in the image, and the stronger the edge contrast, the more prominent it will appear in the sketched version. My local subjects, the succulents along my street, were ideal for this as they had excellent texture and well-defined edges. However, I actually took it a step further and focus-blended most of the the images. Since many of the images were shot with a macro lens, focus-blending eliminated most out-of-focus areas and helped insure the entire image would convert well as a sketch.

The converted RAW file is on the left and the finished sketch is on the right. The sketch technique enhances both color and edges. Color sketches often soften fine textures in the image, which makes the resulting image look more sketch-like. The strong edges, though, become more prominent and make this an ideal image for sketching. Agaves create some of the most beautiful patterns in the Sonoran desert. There is a welcoming softness in the flower-like shape of their leaves, but the sharp tips are a reminder to not get too close.

RAW file conversion and initial sketch

The sketch actions can have quite an impact on the image, though it’s not easy to predict what the image will look like once it’s been converted to a sketch based on the initial RAW fie conversion. As such, I’m not necessarily looking to make a perfect image in Lightroom or Camera Raw. Instead, what I want from RAW conversion is an image that converts well to a sketch, and that usually means a little experimentation. In Camera Raw, I apply a linear profile, click Auto, and then make a few adjustments to balance brightness, color, and saturation. Images that have slightly under-saturated colors tend to work better as sketches since the sketch action usually bumps up saturation. The image is opened as a smart object in Photoshop, and a sketch action is immediately run on it. If it looks good, I’ll work with that sketch from then on. However, if I don’t like it, I’ll delete the group containing the sketch layers and tweak the RAW file by double-clicking on the smart object’s thumbnail to do additional processing in Camera Raw. I go back and forth this way, creating a new sketch after each RAW file adjustment, until I get a sketch I like. In this way, RAW file conversion and making the initial sketch are essentially one step. This initial sketch, created immediately after RAW file conversion, becomes the base image for additional development in Photoshop. Running sketch actions on different RAW conversions lets me zero in on the best starting point for developing the sketch in Photoshop.

These images demonstrate the enhanced color and edges that come from running the Color Sketch action. The image can look quite photographic still, but often much improved compared to the RAW conversion. These are cereus cactus flowers that bloom for just one night each year.

Color Sketch or B&W Sketch?

There are two sketch actions: Color Sketch and B&W Sketch. Which to use is often a matter of personal preference, and I’ll sometimes try both to see if I prefer one over the other. The actions make it easy to try both, and there’s no easy way to predict which will look best. One thing to keep in mind is that the Color Sketch sometimes pulls unexpected colors out of the deep-shadow areas or adds excessive color saturation to some areas, like blue skies, and if these don’t look right with the image, then the B&W Sketch might be the preferred alternative. However, even with the Color Sketch, overly colorful shadow areas revert back to being quite dark and less colorful after the initial sketch adjustments. Occasionally, over-saturated colors require a little extra effort to control later on, and it’s sometimes better to pull back their saturation in the RAW file before running the Color Sketch action (and is another reason to coordinate RAW file conversion with making the initial sketch).

A black and white sketch-o-graph of an agave clearly shows how the edges of the leaves have been enhanced with a black line, which looks quite natural in this monochrome rendition.

Initial settings

There are two settings needed for making the initial sketch. They’re both easy to set and it’s best to use the same setting on each image, at least to start. The layers produced by the sketch actions mean the initial settings can always be readjusted later.

  • Minimum–The Minimum dialog window opens as the action runs. The default is “4” and it’s best to leave it set to that as it generally produces output that indeed looks like a sketch, at least in the details and textured parts of the image. The Minimum setting creates the black sketch lines that define the sketch look, and the greater the edge contrast, the more prominent the sketch lines. After seeing the initial sketch it’s fine to go back and adjust the Minimum value, but using “4” as the starting point gives a good impression as to how well the image will work as a sketch.
  • Levels adjustment–The final step in the sketch action is the creation of a Levels adjustment layer on top of the other layers in the Sketch group. The Properties panel is opened (if it’s not already open) and the user can then make a Levels adjustment using this layer, and this adjustment is critical in creating the desired look for the sketch. The initial Levels adjustment is also (nearly) the same for every image: Pull the midtones slider to the far right edge of the histogram that’s displayed in the Properties panel. I’m not entirely sure why this works, but it does. This maneuver restores proper global contrast to the image while maintaining its sketch-like quality. Small deviations of where the midtones slider is placed can lead to slightly different (but noticeable) effects, but placing the midtones slider very near the right edge of the histogram is almost always a good starting point.

Adjusting the sketch

Once you’re satisfied with the initial sketch, there are still ways to fine-tune it. The image below shows the Layers panel after running the Sketch action and the main controls for adjusting the sketch after it’s been made.

  1. Minimum–Because a smart object is used to make the sketch, it’s easy to go back and adjust it. The main thing to experiment with is the Minimum setting. Simply double-click the word “Minimum” to open the Minimum dialog widow. Try settings in increments of 2 in order to see an effect. The default is “4” so try “2,” “6,” or even “8.” Higher numbers make the image darker and the black sketch lines more prominent. Lower numbers make the image lighter with less prominent sketch lines.
  2. Sketch group opacity–Lowering the opacity of the sketch group allows more of the original image to show through. This can make the result look more photographic and less sketch-like.
  3. Add a layer mask to the sketch group and paint black to conceal parts of the image–Some elements in an image, like sky and clouds, might not look as good after the sketch action runs while other parts with more texture and detail might look great. Adding a layer mask to the sketch group provides an easy way to conceal elements that don’t sketch well while revealing those that do.
  4. Change the sketch group blend mode–This is particularly useful when making a B&W Sketch. In this case, changing the sketch group layer’s blend mode to Luminosity changes the monochrome sketch into a color sketch, but with added detail compared to what the Color Sketch action provides. The video below by Dave Kelly has a nice demonstration of this.

Finishing the image

While the sketch action provides a significant transformation from the RAW conversion, it doesn’t finish the image. I see the sketch as providing a new base for further development. Burning, dodging, vignettes, adjustment through masks and even creative techniques, like glows, can still be used once a satisfactory sketch is in place. The sketch itself can look quite good sometimes, but that’s partly because it’s such a dramatic shift compared to how the image looked before running the sketch action. It’s fun to see what the sketch can do, but don’t hesitate to push further. Think about and experiment with additional possibilities. The sketch can certainly create a new creative path, but it will be up to you to follow it and see where it leads.

The image on the left is the focus-blended RAW file conversion. The finished image on the right shows the enhanced detail and color that were added with the Color Sketch action plus additional post-processing. This is a Santa Rita cactus that develops this purple/blue color as it dries out. Despite the extremely dry winter, it still managed to produce a large number of buds this spring.

Sketch-o-graph video tutorial

Dave Kelly does a nice job reviewing several of these steps in working with the sketch actions in the video below.

Additional examples

I’ve included some images from Steve Dell and Bob Hills below to show the variety of images possible from using this sketch technique.

The first gallery shows some Steve Dell’s sketch images. They again demonstrate how images with good detail work nicely with the sketch technique. In the image with the clouds, the clouds still pretty much look like un-sketched clouds. This is typical of image elements that lack distinct edges.

Bob Hill’s images below are from his “Sonoran Garden” series. Again, the texture and detail in these subjects create strong sketch images. Worth noting are how the distinct lines between shadow and sunlit areas on the leaves create even stronger lines in the sketched versions. In addition, the shadows are less dark and filled with more color.

I hope you’ll give the sketch actions a try. Sketch-o-graphs are easy to make and can produce some surprisingly unique and attractive images.

TK8: Color grading with masks

Color grading is the process of adding color to an image beyond the normal or natural color balance that existed when the photograph was taken. It has traditionally been used in films to impart a specific mood, like the color green that signaled the characters were inside the matrix in the “The Matrix” movie franchise. Photographs, however, can also benefit from color grading, and have actually been doing so for a long time. Things like warming up the colors for images taken around sunset and adding extra blue to images of ice and snow are common examples.

“Morpheus” from The Matrix movies. Notice how the green color grading lets viewers know he is inside the matrix. Image copyrighted by Warner Brothers.

Lightroom and Camera Raw added color-wheel-based color grading in 2020. Color grading an image could now be accomplished by simply dragging and dropping an icon on the color wheel to add that color to either the shadows, midtones, or highlights.

Camera Raw color grading interface.

Photoshop, however, still lacks a similar feature. Curves, Levels, or Color Balance adjustments layers can be used for color grading, but doing so requires using multiple points on the Curves adjustment layer or adjusting multiple sliders on Levels and Color Balance. There is no native, drag-and-drop color grading tool inside Photoshop.

The TK8 plugin now adds color-wheel-based color grading to Photoshop. Shadows, midtones, and highlights can all be adjusted by simply dragging and dropping a matching icon (black, gray, or white square) on the color wheel. The further the square is placed from the center of the color wheel, the more intense the color. In addition to changing colors, the brightness of the different tonal ranges can also be adjusted with the slider at the bottom of the interface.

TK8 color grading interface.

Using a color wheel greatly simplifies the color-grading process. Multiple colors and intensities can quickly be tested to find the right one. And while it’s certainly possible to color grade the entire image using the TK8 color grading interface, the real power of this feature lies in combining it with the different masks that the TK8 Multi-Mask module generates. Color grading has traditionally been associated with more global color adjustments to the image, but the TK8 masks allows it to be more specific and localized, while still providing the easy control that comes with the color-wheel interface. There’s even a specific color grading button in the module’s output section to a) automatically create the necessary color grading layer with the mask preview as the layer mask, and b) open the color grading interface to allow quick access to this functionality.

Red outline shows the color grading output button.

Color grading through masks also simplifies the entire color grading process. When color grading the entire image, it might be necessary to color grade all three tonal ranges—highlights, midtones, and shadows—to get the desired look. However, when color grading through a mask, it’s often NOT necessary to use all three tonal ranges. Simply color grading the midtones, for example, might be all that’s necessary to achieve the effect you’re looking for.

In the video below, Dave Kelly demonstrates how to combine color grading with different pixel-based masks generated with the TK8 Multi-Mask plugin. He first demonstrates color grading the entire image, but then starts narrowing it down, color grading the background separately. He then goes even further to work with luminosity masks, zone masks, and color masks as ways to constrain color grading to specific parts of the image. He even throws in using the mask calculator in the Multi-Mask module as a way to focus color grading right where it’s needed.

Color-wheel-based color grading provides a new option for controlling color inside Photoshop. Combining it with masks can make color adjustments even easier.

Be sure to subscribe to Dave Kelly’s YouTube channel for more TK8 videos.

Personalizing TK8

Over the years I’ve received several suggestions on ways users want to customize their Photoshop panels in order to find their favorite features more easily. I liked these ideas and incorporated most of them. I’ve been pleasantly surprised at how doing so definitely makes modules like Combo and Cx easier to use both in terms of finding the things I use most and also finding my way around these modules in general. If you’ve not already done so, I suggest trying some of the things listed below. In the video at the end of this blog, Dave Kelly demonstrates how to access and set up many of the customization options in more detail.

The preferences interface is the place to start personalizing TK8. It’s accessed via the “TK” button on the main interface of each module. For example, in the Combo module’s preferences shown below, the color saturation of the buttons throughout the panel can be set with the “Button Color” slider (green box) and the user interface language can be set with the language buttons (red box).

Other options here include whether or not you want tooltips to show all the time. Unchecking the “Show tooltips” checkbox once you know your way around TK8 turns off the “always-on” tooltips, but still allows you to access them by holding down the “ALT” key on Windows or the “option” key on Mac.

Whether or not to uncheck “Close TK ►” and “Close User ►” checkboxes is best explained in Dave Kelly’s video below. Unchecking these provides a method to better utilize both the Combo and Cx modules at the same time.

Beyond the preferences section for each module, there are two other customization pathways.

  • Color-tagging–Buttons, TK actions, and User actions can all be highlighted to make your favorites more visible. This can be particularly useful for creating your personal roadmap for the main user interface on the Combo and Cx modules. Once you tag your favorite buttons with a brighter color, you’ll likely use them more frequently. They’ll also serve as guideposts for finding other less-frequently used button on the module. So definitely color-tag your favorite buttons and actions as it makes the Combo and Cx modules more user-friendly.
  • Personal actions–Button actions, the Instant Action, and User actions are all places where each user can insert their own favorite personal actions into the Combo and Cx modules. The new method for adding personal actions in TK8 is very easy, so there’s no reason not to give it a try. The buttons outlined in red below can all be reprogrammed and renamed to run personal actions, and once again, Dave Kelly shows how to do it in the video. Even more, Dave also shows the method for adding ANY menu item to the panel as a personal action.

There are a couple of important things to know about personal actions. They are added from actions already recorded in Photoshop’s regular Actions panel. For button actions, you want to give these actions short names so that the name fits on the button it’s assigned to. Usually three to five characters depending on the width of the button. However, you can also use two words. The two words will “wrap” on the button and still fit with one word above the other. So, if you’re actions have long names, it’s best to rename them in Photoshop’s Actions panel before adding them to the Combo and Cx modules. This is easily done by double-clicking the action’s name on the Actions panel. Also, for any action that will be added to the module, avoid special characters in the name. Action names consisting of letters and numbers only are best to insure that the actions run properly when added to the module.

I think you’ll enjoy the video below. Dave Kelly does a nice job of demonstrating how to personalize TK8 in order to get the most out of it.